Mayor’s Proposal for Rent-Controlled Homes for Key Workers

London Mayor Sadiq Khan has unveiled plans to deliver 6,000 rent-controlled homes for key workers by 2030. The scheme, branded as the ‘Key Worker Living Rent’ initiative, proposes letting new homes at rents set at 40% of key workers’ average net household incomes. This approach is designed to provide an affordable option for long-term renting without requiring tenants to purchase a share of the property either initially or later.

Khan emphasises the importance of supporting essential workers such as teachers, nurses, police officers, and bus drivers, who contribute significantly to the city’s functioning. He encourages housing associations and local councils to collaborate with City Hall and apply for funding through the Affordable Homes Programme to deliver these homes.

Supporters Highlight the Need Amid Rising London Rents

Ben Twomey, chief executive of Generation Rent, welcomed the announcement, highlighting the pressure of soaring rents that have made London the most expensive city to live in Europe. He stated: “Key workers are the backbone of our communities… Yet many are being priced out of the very city they serve.” Twomey described the rent control proposal as a positive initial step towards stabilising rents for key workers and creating genuinely affordable housing options.

Criticism from City Hall Conservatives

Despite the positive reception from some quarters, the City Hall Conservatives have criticised the plan, warning that rent controls have historically failed to deliver promised benefits. Lord Bailey AM, the Conservative housing spokesperson, remarked: “Rent controls always sound good, and they never deliver what’s promised. They haven’t worked anywhere they’ve been tried, and we only need to look at what’s happened in Scotland to see how quickly the headlines fade and the problems deepen.”

Bailey pointed to an 84% collapse in housebuilding in London under Khan’s tenure as the more pressing issue affecting housing affordability. He argued that restricting rents without increasing supply ultimately reduces choice and pushes key workers further from their communities.

Lessons from Scotland’s Rent Control Experience

The criticism references recent data from Scotland, where rent controls were introduced in September 2022. Analysis by DJ Alexander Ltd, Scotland’s largest letting agency, shows that rents for one-bedroom flats increased by £138 (31.2%) between 2010 and 2022. In the two years following rent control implementation, similar properties saw a further £130 (22.4%) rise, indicating that rent controls have not curbed rent inflation as intended.

This evidence is used to caution against relying on rent controls as a solution in London, suggesting that such policies may inadvertently accelerate rent increases rather than stabilise them.

Implications for Landlords and Letting Agents

For landlords and letting agents in London, the Mayor’s rent-controlled homes plan signals a potential shift towards income-linked rents for a specific segment of tenants—key workers. While these homes represent a small proportion of the overall market, the broader debate highlights ongoing challenges in balancing affordability with housing supply.

The criticism from opposition parties underscores the importance of increasing housebuilding rates to meet demand, rather than relying solely on rent regulation. Landlords should monitor developments closely, as any expansion of rent control policies could influence rental market dynamics and investment decisions.

Conclusion

Sadiq Khan’s rent-controlled homes plan aims to address affordability for key workers in London but faces significant scepticism regarding its effectiveness and potential unintended consequences. The debate reflects wider tensions in London’s housing market between controlling costs and ensuring sufficient supply, a balance that remains critical for landlords, agents, and tenants alike.

Suggested internal link anchors

• rent-controlled homes London
• affordable housing schemes
• key worker housing
• London housebuilding rates
• rent control policies
• private rented sector challenges
• impact of rent controls
• housing supply and demand
• London rental market
• letting agents and landlords

TLA update

TLA is launching a new Trusted Partners Hub in Q1 2026, featuring verified and approved service providers selected to support landlords, tenants, and property management businesses. We are inviting legal, trades, insurance, financial, mortgage, tenant screening, and other service providers to register their interest here: https://landlordassociation.org.uk/become-a-tla-service-partner/